Working Live Today

Posted: 2009-09-4 8:00

Key:
Tasks on list at start of day
Current Task

Actioned tasks
(numbered in order of completion)
Tasks added during day

[Tasks marked for review]
—————————— = Start of Open List
(1156) timed log entry (at end)

THE LIST

13 Cancel Insurance Policies (1018)
15 Write Henry S. (1053)
[Contribute to P & Y’s Charity]
10 Buy Guillotine
[Weed Old Accounts]
[Ring Ben’s Gutters]
[Get Phoenix Insurance Claim signed]
[Investigate ways of marketing and selling E-book]
[Approaching businesses?]
11 Photo Plus Manual
[Sort out Domain hosting]
14 Photos for Facebook
12 “Taxi Driver”
[“Fanny Cradock”]
[“I Know Where I’m Going”]
[“The Edge of the World”] [1452][1534]
——————————————
Check details needed by Travel Agency
56 Schedule for Newsletters?
16 Restaurant for L’s birthday?
Card for L
Weed Noguchi
57 Portuguese 17
Aeneid
“Then She Found Me”
Write E-book
Write M
67 Read “Ultra Simple Guide”
Camera Manual
Return chalk to T
Brain trainer
17 Tidy Office
68 “Fleurs du Mal”
18 Make Bed
German 24/3
19 Facebook
50 Spanish 12/2
Mow Lawn
Sort out Google bar
Blog “7 Habits of Poor Time Managers”
“Saraband”
Write
20 Bureau Top tidy?
21 MicroPlaza
Reading List (oldest)
Reading List (newest)
G replied?
22 Desk tidy?
23 Exercise
Walk
Tax Return
Photo Galleries
Squarespace Videos
47 Check BP
Journal 10+
24 Investment Managers
25 RegZooka
26 Cut Hedge
27 NumberWatch
28 Carswell
69 “The Cell” (2300)
Paper
1 Comments (0800)
2 Voicemail

29 Fix date for lunch with Carol N
3 Email
4 FTSE (0833)
“Top Gear”
5 Lowest Point Forecast
30 Back Up
31 Reading
6 Doodle
Change Wallpaper
58 Reading List (quality)
7 Pitch C#
8 Wash Up
Autopager?
Firefox extension name?
9 Comments

Voicemail
32 Email
33 FTSE
Lowest Point Forecast
Doodle
34 Pitch C#
35 Wash Up
36 Comments (0904)
PhotoPlus Manual
“Taxi Driver”
Cancel Avon Policy
48 To Think About
37
L replied re Henry?

38 L replied re restaurant?
Check Porsche Tyres
Check Polo Service
Tidy Office
39 Read Newspaper
40 Check Site Visitors for today
Make Bed
Facebook
51 Find Driving Licence
Bureau Top Tidy?
52 Regenerate Friend Wheel
41 Ordo
Investment Managers
Carswell
59 Carol N replied re lunch?
Diaries of Adrienne v. Speyr?
42 Lunch
53 SpyZooka
RegZooka
54 Reading
Pitch C#
Write Henry
55 Book restaurant
43 Reserve District 9 and Tricks
44 Comments
45 Wash Up
46 Email
Voicemail
56 Site Visitors
Ordo
49 Comments
Wash Up (1450)(1709)(1847)(1849)
—————————————————
Check BP
60 Email
61 Comments (1528)
Check weeding schedule for old accounts
Find Phone Number for Ben’s Gutters
Prepare papers for Phoenix signing
Check domain hosting records
“Fanny Cradock”
Spanish 13
62 Tweetdeck
SpyZooka
63 Reading
64 Site Visitors (2046)
Newsletter Template
Portuguese 17/2
Try out issuu.com
Reading List (quality)
65 Email
66 Tweetdeck
Email (2057)
“Fleurs du Mal”
“The Cell”


0800. The list is divided into two unequal parts, divided by a line ———————. Different rules apply to each part. I am starting where I left off yesterday, near the end of the list. The method here is to move down the list taking action on those tasks which feel ready to be done. I will number tasks in the order they are done so you can follow the sequence. The numbers in brackets after some tasks are times, and refer to the log entries at the end of the list (of which this is the first).

0833. This is reminding me why I hate using electronic means of working a to do list! It’s slowing me down no end. The Squarespace editor is also being annoying - a blank line has appeared in the middle of the list which I don’t seem to be able to get rid of. Never mind!

0904. I’ve now reached the end of the list. My next action is to go to the beginning of the list - into the part of the list before the line (——————). Oooooerrrr!!!

1018. Within the first part of the list, I keep circling round the list until nothing further seems ready to do.

1053. I’ve now been round the first part of the list three times, and there’s nothing further that seems ready to do. So now I start on the second part of the list. I only do one pass of this before going back to the first part.

1450. Now reached the end of the list for the second time today. So back to the first part of the list (the “backlog”)

1452. None of the tasks in the “backlog” stand out for action so I have marked them all up for review (on paper I would have used a highlighter for this). At the same time I have drawn a line at the end of the list so that the whole current list becomes the “backlog”. All new tasks will now go below this line.

1528. Now reached the end of the list for the third time today. Notice how fast I moved through the list this time. Back to the beginning of the list.

1534. What I have now done is delete all the items marked for review. You will see that I have re-entered some after rephrasing them. One I have re-entered as it was (A recorded TV program that I haven’t yet had time to see). The rest I have dropped altogether because I decided the time wasn’t yet ripe for them.

1709. Reached end of first part of list - back to the beginning. On another subject, this page has been loaded 5,973 times today (and it wasn’t all by me!)

1847 End of first part of list again - back to beginning.

1849 I’ve been round the first part of the list again without any tasks seeming ready to do - so on to the second part.

2046. Page has been accessed 7,507 times today.

2057 Reached the end of the list again. Back to the beginning. I’ll select a next task, but what I’m really going to do is go and watch NCIS on tv!

2300 That’s it for today. 70 tasks completed. 8,604 page views. I hope that’s given everyone a good idea of how powerful the system is. Now I’ve just got to copy everything I’ve done today back into my paper notebook!

(Comments on this post are now closed. If you can’t see the existing comments, click on the post heading “Working Live Today”)


Comments (188)

Wooba - 2009-09-4 8:11
Morning, Mark.

What is the rule for placing the line?
Catus Lee - 2009-09-4 8:18
Mark,

Are you working in AF or AF2?
Jiru - 2009-09-4 8:19
Morning Mark.

I guess placing that line is one of the most important parts of AF4. So I'm really curious to read the rule.
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 8:30
Since Facebook is on your list, which Mark Forster there are you? I didn't see you in the search results I looked through. There is a Mark Forster in the Autofocus Group, but he ... doesn't look anything like you. My profile is here: http://www.facebook.com/andreas.michael.hofmann
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 8:32
I guess the the stuff above the line is the "backlog".
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 8:36
Re facebook: never mind, it seems that is you in the Autofocus Group. ^^
Richard - 2009-09-4 8:45
Boy, I wish I was self-employed and could put, and then action, "Doodle" on my list...! ;-)
clay - 2009-09-4 8:52
good guess, andreas. would make sense if below the line was an open list. i don't think mark is going to tell us much, at least early on. we'll probably have to infer things.
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 8:57
Richard:

<< Boy, I wish I was self-employed and could put, and then action, "Doodle" on my list...! ;-) >>

Like many of the entries that has a cryptic meaning which only I understand!
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 8:58
Andreas:

<< There is a Mark Forster in the Autofocus Group, but he ... doesn't look anything like you. >>

He looks like I looked in 1975!
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 8:59
Andreas:

<< I guess the the stuff above the line is the "backlog". >>

Correct, though I prefer not to call it that.
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 9:01
Catus Lee:

Are you working in AF or AF2?

The fourth (unpublished) version. See http://www.markforster.net/autofocus-index/
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 9:02
Wooba:

<< What is the rule for placing the line? >>

It goes at the end of the whole list when the previous "backlog" is completed. So three days ago that line included the whole list.
learning as I go - 2009-09-4 9:19
Hi Mark
It's 4:14 am here......I'm drugged and riding out the pain via your live blog. Thanks for the entertainment. The tv only has junk shows and infomercials. I have my music going also. Because I'm still grateful to not have a backlog since you bailed me out of mine a few years ago......I'm am curious as to how you define a backlog these days.....

You stated:
It goes at the end of the whole list when the previous "backlog" is completed. So three days ago that line included the whole list.

Because I work from a weekly format, I'm shocked that you define work less than 3 days old as a backlog! LOL! How do you define it? Even DIT standards allowed up to 4 days to catch up on the loose ends!
learning as I go
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 9:25
<< He looks like I looked in 1975! >>

I figured as much by now. ;-)

I you don't mind another man saying so, you're pretty handsome!
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 9:29
Is "task marked for review" the same as "tasks on notice" or "tasks on review"?
Jonathan - 2009-09-4 9:29
Hi Mark,

Good morning - and what a good idea to try this here. It would be really useful if you can explain in your running commentary today the rules that you are following, and anything that crops up around why you do and don't do certain tasks. Without knowing what the new process is that you are following it is difficult to appreciate how and why the list is being covered. Also why and how there are two lists, or two parts to the list.

Regards,
Jonathan
----
The list is divided into two unequal parts, divided by a line ———————. Different rules apply to each part. I am starting where I left off yesterday, near the end of the list. The method here is to move down the list taking action on those tasks which feel ready to be done.
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 9:31
Learning:

<< Because I work from a weekly format, I'm shocked that you define work less than 3 days old as a backlog! >>

Perhaps that is the reason Mark prefers not to call it a backlog.
Frank - 2009-09-4 9:41
I presume (based on what Mark has said previously) that the completed tasks are only being shown for our benefit - and are not part of the system.

It's fascinating then that Mark is doing all of this electronically. Looks like you could run the whole system within a single electronic note...or even a standard, simple task list as long as you can move the line up and down within it.
learning as I go - 2009-09-4 9:49
Good Morning Andreas H.
This is quite fun....given my options...*blush*....
This is precisely the reason I couldn't follow DIT. I'm a great proponent of planning my weekly outcomes and that necessitates me ignoring the trivia while I'm focused on other work. I'd go completely bonkers if I had to follow the dictates of random stuff streaming in to decide how I spend my limited resources. Even before I was disabled and had a far more rigorous schedule (I lived out of my calendar for ambitious pursuits, competitions and social life and totally off list for my pleasures and passions) Even then, I ignored the trivia unless I had dead space time...(small units of time between important aims or events)
Even though I was quite ambitious, my Bohemian spirit prevailed ultimately. If it was important enough, it put on the calendar. If not, it had to wait until I had dead time.....and I was intent on having very little of that! LOL!
Perhaps, this is why I had such a hard time adjusting my lifestyle to my limitations....It's cruel folly for me to aim very high these days! *blush* My energy and attitude would be severly hampered if I had to chase down backlogs that were less than 3 days old! LOL!

BTW.....how is your back healing? I sincerely hope that you are enjoying better times.
learning as I go
learning as I go - 2009-09-4 9:57
p.s.
Andreas H....could you give me the URL for the hot version of Mark? I'm starving for things to distract me from the flooded brain and sharp pain leaking through the heavy drugs....ahhhh....
1975.....one of the great years!
learning as I go
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 10:00
Learning, my back is doing fine. I have been painless for some weeks now. I'm really lucky there was no lasting damage. I feel a little guilty that I was so lucky when you were not. My best wishes go out to you.
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 10:02
Learning, Mark's facebook profile is here: http://www.facebook.com/people/Mark-Forster/728856766 ;-)
learning as I go - 2009-09-4 10:09
Hi Andreas
PLEASE! Don't feel guilty! I'm GRATEFUL that you are not suffering any more! My gratitudes keep me fueled to keep on.......so actually I sincerely THANK YOU for giving me such GREAT NEWS! Knowing this about you has actually made me feel much better. Andreas, I thank you for that!
learning as I go
learning as I go - 2009-09-4 10:13
Thanks, Andreas!
Mark, is that you circa 1975? You look like you were a famous rocker or actor!
learning as I go
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 10:17
Does “Taxi Driver” mean Mark's now watching a movie and we can check back in 1 1/2 hours? :-)
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 10:25
Apparently not. ^^
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 10:30
So far, this system is resulting in my most unproductive friday ever. ;-)
learning as I go - 2009-09-4 10:30
Hi Andreas
Maybe he has to put it in the post to return it.....Netflix or an equivalent....my sister loves her Netflix.....I can't follow movies without backtracking them over and over. My short term memory limitations can't hold the characters or plot! *blush* Therefore, I rarely attempt to watch a movie unless it seems like it would be worth hours and hours of effort to follow it. The last one I watched was Johnny Cash's bio. It was called "Walk the Line"....yes...it was worth it!
learning as I go
AndreasE - 2009-09-4 10:34
Fascinating! Better than a webcam, I'd say... ;-)

I suppose the dismissal rule will be that once you enter the backlog and find no task standing out in the first pass-though, you dismiss the whole backlog and draw the new divider line below the open list.

This is... awesome! Makes RAF looking old and clunky.
learning as I go - 2009-09-4 10:37
Hi Andreas
"So far, this system is resulting in my most unproductive friday ever. ;-)
September 4, 2009 at 10:30 | Andreas Hofmann"

ROTFL! It's only 5:30am here so I have no agenda yet....except to walk the dog when the sun rise.....I LOVE that ritual....even at a snail's pace. Plus, no one is around to see me with my embarrassing looking three legged cane! LOL! When people are about, I try not to use it.............talk about ridiculous ego decisions! LOL!
learning as I go
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 10:38
Hi Learning, must be something different, because he re-added it. Or he put it in an envelope and when he next comes to it, he'll put stamp on it or mail it.

Well, perhaps it's not the most important aspect to pay attention to. ;-)

Does the cycling through the backlog (what *do* you prefer to call it, Mark?) work like cycling through a page in AF1/Forward Mode? If you do a complete pass without actioning anything, you leave the backlog?
learning as I go - 2009-09-4 10:54
hi Andreas
Maybe he's waiting for a bundle of things to carry to the mail box.
I'm starting to feel like a voyeur! *blush*......I'll walk the dog to shake off that feeling! Just kidding!
learning as I go
learning as I go - 2009-09-4 11:04
Hi Andreas
You stated:
"I suppose the dismissal rule will be that once you enter the backlog and find no task standing out in the first pass-though, you dismiss the whole backlog and draw the new divider line below the open list."

HOLY MOLY! Are you asserting that everything above today's italicized entries would become the new backlog?
And what is the fate of the original backlog items?....or does it all become an even bigger lump or............scary thought..........the current backlog gets dismissed?
That sounds like lightening speed! A mid day nap or an impromptu social visit could throw off the whole thing! LOL! WAY too fast for the like of me! LOL!
learning as I go
Frank - 2009-09-4 11:05
Just in case anyone's interested, the SiteDelta addon for Firefox works really well for watching this live experiment - makes it very obvious how Mark is working the list.
learning as I go - 2009-09-4 11:09
p.s.
You stated in another post:
"Does the cycling through the backlog (what *do* you prefer to call it, Mark?) work like cycling through a page in AF1/Forward Mode? If you do a complete pass without actioning anything, you leave the backlog?"

I would guess not....not having a consequence of not acting on it procedurally would be too willy nilly.....His recent blog posts and comments infer that he's incorporating more procedural discipline into the new system to ensure progress and prevent willful avoidance/neglect.
learning as I go
Frank - 2009-09-4 11:09
"I suppose the dismissal rule will be that once you enter the backlog and find no task standing out in the first pass-though, you dismiss the whole backlog and draw the new divider line below the open list."

I think that would be too drastic...probably dismissing whatever is left at the end of the day might be better...though even that is pretty drastic.
Jacqueline - 2009-09-4 11:25
Wow, this really brings home to me why I have to prioritize and dismiss a lot to keep up and MF does not.
learning as I go - 2009-09-4 11:25
Hi Frank
I totally concur with your sentiments!.......but then again, he's working off his list from 8am to 11pm..................that's PLENTY of time to knock out quite a bit of work! He has stated previously that he almost lives out of his list. Therefore, it's hard for me to guess how he's thinking. My goal is to get myself OUT of my list ASAP each day! I'll have to defer to your AF knowledge and experience in these matters.
learning as I go
AndreasE - 2009-09-4 11:26
I don't find this drastic. You might very well work on a backlog (=the part of the list ABOVE the divider line) several days. You just have to find anything in it to work on.

But "dismiss it if on the first pass no task stands out" would be a very AF-like rule.
AndreasE - 2009-09-4 11:28
>>Are you asserting that everything above today's italicized entries would become the new backlog?<<

No. The whole second part of the list will become the backlog the moment the momentary backlog gets dismissed.

That's only my assumption, of course.
learning as I go - 2009-09-4 11:31
Morning Jacq
I don't understand what you mean.....how does Mark's way differ from yours other than prioritizing....???? Is he displaying a superior method that my uneducated eyes (non AF mentality or experience) are missing?
learning as I go
Mike - 2009-09-4 11:32
Hey Learning,

I scored a copy of "The West Wing" (the pilot episode) if you are interested. I have not done more than that (i.e. find an upload site where I could place it so you could download it at your leisure) in case you are not interested upon further reflection.

However, if you are, send an email with your email address to my new dummy email address:

Erik.Satie@softhome.net

and I'll work out the details. (I was in a fit of musical whimsy when I made that one up! ;-) I've done it before so it should not be a big deal.

Fun stuff, this watching Mark go about his routine. It gives an interesting insight into how the world looks to him. He certainly DOES put everything on his list. LOL ;-)
learning as I go - 2009-09-4 11:33
I'll be back.......suns coming up....don't want to miss it....
I'm sure I'll be gifted with more of your great minds trying to solve the mystery! This is great fun!
learning as I go
Mike - 2009-09-4 11:35
Andreas,

I wonder if it would be more likely that a new backlog would not be declared until the next day. That is what I would do. I can't see including an item I just wrote on the bottom of the list a minute ago to be part of a "backlog". But then, Mark has said he is not calling it a "backlog" so that may be why he might do something like that. Sometimes terminology is king ;-)
Frank - 2009-09-4 11:38
@AndreasE,

"I don't find this drastic. You might very well work on a backlog (=the part of the list ABOVE the divider line) several days. You just have to find anything in it to work on."

In Mark's comment at 10.53, he states he did not find anything to work on above-the-line...and he didn't dismiss the above-the-line tasks.

I was suspecting that Mark would put everything above the line on review at the beginning of the day (to be dismissed the day after). But he didn't start off with anything in review, so that seems to negate that theory.
Jacqueline - 2009-09-4 11:43
Hey learning,
It's that everything that he's doing in 15 hours are things I'd like to do too - but only have about 3 hours to do it in. Because I'm not retired with no kids.
I think most people that have a full time job and families have to figure out what their priorities are.

Mike, I'm worried that he's not eating though. Maybe today is a fasting day?
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 11:43
Frank:

<>

Yes, but he did action several tasks above the line before that pass. So it could still be like a AF1 page. No action on first pass -> dismiss, no action on later pass -> leave backlog.

I have a feeling we won't see any dismissing today.

Re SiteDelta: Yes, it's really great for this. I primed it yesterday to watch the blog area and I also told it to keep backup copies of the changes. So I can go back in time and watch it step by step.
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 11:48
Mike:

<>

Mark stated concerning the backlog line:

<< It goes at the end of the whole list when the previous "backlog" is completed. >>

I think that would include doing everything as well as dismissing everything.
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 11:52
What I like so far is that it really removes emphasis from working on the latest and loudest in that the recently added tasks are only passed once. That was the greatest flaw with AF2/RAF in my eyes.
Frank - 2009-09-4 11:56
@Andreas Hofmann

"Yes, but he did action several tasks above the line before that pass. So it could still be like a AF1 page. No action on first pass -> dismiss, no action on later pass -> leave backlog. "

Yes, I see what you mean - that would probably work quite well.

And then all the tasks in that first section get put on review - to be dismissed the following day if no action is taken.

In the meantime, the open list becomes the next closed list by moving the line to the bottom of the list.
Frank - 2009-09-4 12:13
"And then all the tasks in that first section get put on review - to be dismissed the following day if no action is taken."

Just to respond to my own comment... :)

I think instead it would work more intuitively if the tasks currently on "review" would be dismissed the next time the line is moved to declare a new "backlog".

(There must be a "review" element because Mark mentions that in the key to his list )
Joseph - 2009-09-4 12:39
Andreas H.

Any chance you might (assuming Mr. Forster is ok with it) someday post the whole series of lists to wiki? I'm in the U.S., and wasn't up early enough to watch the early iterations.

(I was trying to think of a way to log them, I didn't realize siteDelta could have done it. I laughed when you posted your comment about that because last night I had thought to myself "If anyone would know how to record blog post changes it would be Andreas. Guess I was right!).

Thanks,
Joseph
Frank - 2009-09-4 12:53
I've got some free time today so I'm trying out Mark's new system (or what we've collectively managed to figure out ) on my PDA.

You can skip the need for having a line just by having two task lists, or two folders of tasks...one called "Backlog" and one called "Current", and just move tasks between them as required.

So far it feels like using AF1 again (which is great) but with the added advantage of the open list to handle urgent items.
Mike - 2009-09-4 12:57
Jacqueline,

Eating: ROTFLMAO ;-) ;-) It could be that he is doing all of this before lunch? Or, perhaps between lunch and dinner? LOL ;-)
Matt - 2009-09-4 13:04
Hi Frank,

If you're sorting by creation date, you could just add a task with the subject line of:

"-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------"

Looks OK in Outlook,

Matt
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 13:07
Mike:

<< It could be that he is doing all of this before lunch? >>

Everything so far has been between breakfast and lunch. Time here in UK is currently 1.07pm
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 13:09
Joseph:

<< Any chance you might (assuming Mr. Forster is ok with it) someday post the whole series of lists to wiki? >>

You can follow the whole thing simply by looking at the tasks in order (each completed task is numbered) and reading the timed log entries (which are all referenced to the list).
Mike - 2009-09-4 13:11
Mark,

Yeah, just subtract 5 ;-)

When I saw "change wallpaper" on your list I thought "Egad, this must be superman. It takes me a couple of days to wallpaper a room!" Then I decided you must mean the wallpaper on your computer monitor! LOL ;-)

This really is great fun.
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 13:11
Andreas:

<< I have a feeling we won't see any dismissing today. >>

I have a feeling you will!
Mike - 2009-09-4 13:13
Yeah, I was grumbling about this odd way of showing it, but it really is easy enough to follow.
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 13:18
<< Does “Taxi Driver” mean Mark's now watching a movie and we can check back in 1 1/2 hours? :-) >>

Yes, I was watching a movie, but you ought to know me well enough to know that I do things little and often. I watched about 30 minutes of it.
ludlow - 2009-09-4 13:19
I'm slightly confused. (This is normal for me...) Are we watching the live demonstration of a system that hasn't yet been fully explained to us? I guess I am finding it hard to see what the point of that is, other than to tease us for when AF4 is revealed...!
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 13:20
Ludlow:

<< Are we watching the live demonstration of a system that hasn't yet been fully explained to us? >>

It's being explained as I go along. By the time today ends (accidents excepted) you should have the entire system.
ludlow - 2009-09-4 13:21
Ah, got it. Thanks.
Mike - 2009-09-4 13:23
The point of it is to make the peanut gallery shut up! LOL ;-) We have been bugging Mark about it and he is not yet ready to release it so he is just letting us watch. At least that is what my recent attempt at reading Mark's mind tells me ;-)

And, BTW, this is so much MORE instructive than just a list of rules and a "go try it" admonition. Seeing it in action reveals so much about how it works in practice. I, for one, really appreciate Mark's doing this.
Mike - 2009-09-4 13:25
... moreover, how impressive is it that Mark can work his list all the while commenting to us and responding to questions?
Frank - 2009-09-4 13:27
@Matt,

Yes, you could use a "----" subject line separator but I've found from using AF1 on my Blackberry in the past that the closed list effect works much more effectively for me to have a reducing task list. It seems to focus my mind a lot more on those unpleasant tasks when I can see there are only a few items left.
Mike - 2009-09-4 13:35
... yeee gods, Mark is also Twittering as he goes! ROTF ;-)
Matt - 2009-09-4 13:53
Hi Frank,

Makes sense. I find it varies with me depending on screen size. The small BB screen gets too cluttered with done tasks. At work I run Outlook on a large monitor and the extra real-estate makes it comfortable to have completed tasks showing. Plus, strikethrough on Outlook completed tasks is more intuitive somehow.

So, I'm going for this new approach as well. At least I think I am from what's been posted so far. I assume I draw a line. Above the line I keep rotating thrugh AF1 style until nothing stands out. Then I parse below the line, once, before returning above the line.

Is that how everyone elses reads it?

Matt
AndreasE - 2009-09-4 14:02
I might be wrong, but in the moment, AF4 appears to be basically AF1 on a larger scale. (Which would explain the addictive effect... :-D)

Imagine doing AF1 with only 2 active pages, one of them being the last page (where you add new tasks and don't dismiss). Only difference: There is no limit in length. Page 1 is closed, that means, you can't add tasks anymore, you can only get tasks done. Page 2 is open, you can add to it. So, page 1 would be the first part of the list (the not-so-called "backlog"), and page 2 the second part.

I wonder how wrong I am...
David Drake - 2009-09-4 14:04
Mark,

Are you planning on posting the rules today for your new system -- which looks fantastic -- by the end of your online demonstration today? That would be great!

-David
Mike - 2009-09-4 14:10
What we think we know so far:

- Two lists (or list parts)
- First is a closed list (not) called "Backlog"
- - Is cycled through until nothing stands out
- - Don't know about dismissal yet
- Second is an open list
- - It is worked when nothing stands out from the first list
- - Don't know about dismisal yet (I suspect there is no dismissal from the open list)
- Return to the first list after working the second list once through (?)

If there was nothing more to it than that, it would be pretty powerful, IMO.
ds - 2009-09-4 14:20
Thanks for that summary, Mike. It's starting to sound like a murder mystery, isn't it?
Frank - 2009-09-4 14:21
Maybe we should just all agree to call the "not-backlog" list a "backlog" list for sanity's sake? :)

I can see why it isn't a true backlog (because potentially a newish task could end up there) but that list does get treated like a backlog (i.e. it gets isolated and then chipped away bit by bit) and it's going to get awfully confusing if we don't standardize on some terminology.
Rainer - 2009-09-4 14:24
Isn't the not-backlog list just "yesterday's list"?
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 14:29
Andreas:

<< I wonder how wrong I am... >>

Actually that's quite a good summary.
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 14:31
David:

<< Are you planning on posting the rules today for your new system -- which looks fantastic -- by the end of your online demonstration today? >>

You've got most of it already, see Andreas and Mike's summaries.

Just the dismissal/review stage to come.
Frank - 2009-09-4 14:32
@Rainer,

My theory is that dismissal is not based on time for this system but on whether any items in the "backlog" list can be done or not. I'm guessing that if no items stand out at all, then all these items are put up for review and then dismissed on the next "backlog declaration".

So really there is no concept of "yesterday" for this approach...my deductions are based primarily on the fact that Mark started where he left off yesterday...and, of course, I could be completely wrong :)
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 14:33
Rainer:

<< Isn't the not-backlog list just "yesterday's list"? >>

No, it's not day specific.
ds - 2009-09-4 14:34
"Isn't the not-backlog list just "yesterday's list"?"

Now it's starting to sound like a Bob Dylan song!
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 14:34
Frank:

<< I could be completely wrong >>

Not completely :-)
James T - 2009-09-4 14:49
A key issue regarding the workability of the new system is going to be the balance between the two lists (ie the one before the line and the one after it). If the first list is so long that you do not often get to the second list you have a problem analogous to the one that some of us had with AF1 (ie not getting to the newest items often enough). In the case of Mark's demonstration today, the first list is short enough that Mark can cycle round it several times and still get to the second list twice (?) so far today.
Mel - 2009-09-4 14:56
Mark, given that you are washing up again, I would say you are a very clean person. :-) I am sure I will like this latest approach, but it's a potential bummer for software developers working on AF. I wonder what would happen to all our productivity if we had a live audience watching. My audience would be thinking, "Good grief. She's still reading comments on Mark's blog. Get moving already." So I think I will. ;-)
Frank - 2009-09-4 15:02
@James T

If the "backlog" list is operated as an AF1 list in this new system then you would only need to do one item on it in order to move to the open list again - so length would not really be a major issue.
Mike - 2009-09-4 15:07
Frank,

Re: Sanity ;-) I agree that terminology is important so we ought to pick our terms carefully.

At one point I said to myself: "Self, his backlog is nothing more than my "hot list"." On further reflection that is not true at all. While it may be that much of what is on the backlog is "hot", that does not correctly describe it.

Likewise, I think "backlog" is not right because some things there may be current.

I think when mark states his "rule" for drawing the line (especially drawing it next time) we will have more insight into what that line really MEANS. Knowing that, we will be able to devise meaningful terminology (or perhaps Mark has already).

I'm happy to call it the (not) backlog list for now ;-) Or we could call it the Ostrich list ... no, I prefer the Cat list ... I love cats ;-)
Joseph - 2009-09-4 15:07
Mr. Forster,

Thank you for the advice on how to follow the progress. I see now how to read this blog post to "recreate" the sequence of events.

Since some comments have been speculation about the actual activities on the list, I want to add that I got excited when I notice ORDO on your list! Could that have been the Divine Office (Liturgy of the Hours)? Happy feast of St. Rosalia!

--Joseph
Mike - 2009-09-4 15:09
Frank,

Re: Length ... are you sure? Length seems to be a killer under any set of rules. I would say that if you can't get through the list AT LEAST once per day (and that is at the ragged edge of acceptable IMO) then the list (or list section) is too long.
SteveB - 2009-09-4 15:10
@James

I agree in general - the balance will almost certainly be key - but I think it includes an important mechanism that AF1 lacked... namely the option to "shortcut-out" to the newer items.

What I mean is, suppose you are feeling time-pressured by a recently added or nearly-urgent item (or items), or even just by a nagging feeling there's "something you're missing" in the second part of the list:

In AF4, this is likely to reduce the extent to which items in part 1 feel ready to be done, so you're likely to swiftly switch to part 2. In AF1 however, unless you adopted a 'tweak', you would have to do at least something on at least one item on every page between where you were and the last page, which would likely be a lot slower.

It looks like a more easily managed approach to an idea I was just about to test for an AF1 tweak (having found myself with AF2 doing 'more', but primarily lots of repetitions of less important stuff like reading RSS feeds) - which was going to be the choice every time I moved to the next page of instead flipping to the last (or perhaps last but one) page and then returning to the 'real' next page after I reached the end.
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 15:16
James T@

<< If the first list is so long that you do not often get to the second list you have a problem analogous to the one that some of us had with AF1 >>

No, not really. Notice how fast I progressed up the list immediately after closing it.
Sabrina - 2009-09-4 15:17
I love the way AF4 is returning to the simplicity of AF1! Thanks for sharing the latest and greatest with us, Mark.

Now the question remains - when are the 'marked for review' tasks reviewed?
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 15:19
Mel:

<< I would say you are a very clean person. >>

I work on a little and often basis. Washing up isn't a big chore if there are only a few items to wash up. If you wait until there are tons, then it becomes a huge task. Same with email, paper, tidying, cutting the hedge, etc. etc. I always work to zero with my in-box and similar items.
Mike - 2009-09-4 15:20
Second version of what we think we know so far:

- Two lists (or list parts)
- First is a closed list (not) called "Backlog"
- - Is cycled through until nothing stands out
- - If nothing stands out:
- - - All items are put "on review"
- - - The "backlog line" is moved to the end of the second list making all of that a "backlog"
- - - All new items are added after the new line
- - - We don't yet know about dismissal
- Second is an open list
- - It is worked when nothing stands out from the first list
- - It is worked in only one pass then we return to the first list
- - Don't know about dismissal yet (I suspect there is no dismissal from the open list)

Waiting with baited breath for the dismissal rule ;-)
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 15:22
Joseph:

<< Could that have been the Divine Office (Liturgy of the Hours)? >>

I write the Daily Ordo for the Divine Office Group, which uses the Anglican Breviary. This version of AF makes it very easy to stay on top of that task.
Mike - 2009-09-4 15:23
I should have written: "when nothing stands out from the first list after returning to it from the second list (or initially, I suppose), then the items go on notice." Yeah, word smithing needed ;-)
Frank - 2009-09-4 15:23
It seems we have all been taken by surprise (or me, at least ) - the two list system is really a three list system.

We have "current", "backlog" (or not) and "review".

Looks like on the next "rotation" of lists...

1. "Review" will be dismissed
2. "Backlog" becomes "Review"
3. "Current" becomes "Backlog"
4. And anything new or repeated goes into "Current"

Simple and elegant.
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 15:23
Sabrina:

<< when are the 'marked for review' tasks reviewed? >>

You are about to find out!
Brian - 2009-09-4 15:44
Since you didn't have a task to "Review tasks up for review," was this triggered as a structured step in the process?
Mel - 2009-09-4 15:45
Mark, I think it's a language difference. When I read "wash up," I envision you washing your hands and possibly your face. Now if you had written "clean up" or "wash dishes" I would have seen you doing what you described.
Mike - 2009-09-4 15:45
AH HA ;-)

Do we have it all yet? LOL ;-) Here is what I see:

------

Summary of AF4 Rules

AF4 consists of two lists (or list parts)

- The first is a closed list called "Backlog" (for the moment)
- - It is cycled through until nothing stands out
- - If nothing stands out and something was "actioned" on this pass
- - - Move to the second list
- - If nothing was "actioned" on this pass
- - - All items are put "on review"
- - - The "backlog line" is moved to the end of the second list making all of that a "backlog"
- - - All new items are added after the new line
- - If nothing stands out in one pass of the "on notice" section
- - - Dismiss all "on notice" items
- - - Add back any that seem to want to be done to the end of the second list

- Second is an open list
- - It is worked when nothing stands out from the first list
- - It is worked in only one pass then we return to the first list
- - (I suspect there is no dismissal from the open list)

- The two lists are treated as one with regard to where one is in the processing, IOW, start tomorrow where you left off today.
Zytex aka Paul - 2009-09-4 15:46
SteveB wrote
"In AF1 however, unless you adopted a 'tweak', you would have to do at least something on at least one item on every page between where you were and the last page, which would likely be a lot slower."

This is exactly why I like Forward Mode in RAF and use it so much!

I know there are things I must do on my newest page - so I *want* to get to them.
But (following the AF1/RAF rules) I must pick at least one item on each of the earlier pages and make some progress on them in order to get there legally. With that motivation and sense of urgency, I fly through stuff - often just doing just a tiny amount for the chosen tasks - in order to get to the end page and tackle the 'must do' items on it.

Now I know I could just skip to them if I wanted to - but by not allowing myself to do so - and sticking to the 'rules' above, I create a driving force for getting things done that has seen my productivity increase many-fold.

So I wonder if the same effect is what lies behind AF4?

Paul
Carol Davis-Wilkie - 2009-09-4 15:53
Finding it a bit confusing to understand exactly what the new process is re backlogs? Can anyone explain, or must we await AF4?
Brian - 2009-09-4 15:53
And what does it mean if <> was reviewed, deleted, and not re-entered? Help us give you money, man!
Mike - 2009-09-4 15:55
What gives me pause is the huge number of items on the second list ... now the FIRST list, which might possibly be put "on notice". This is exactly the feeling I had with AF2 and which caused me to challenge everything I put on the list to limit list size.
Mike - 2009-09-4 15:59
Carol,

>>> Finding it a bit confusing to understand exactly what the new process is re backlogs? Can anyone explain, or must we await AF4? <<<

If on any "first pass" of the "first list" (IOW, after you have come from the second list and do a pass of the first list) nothing stands out to be done then ALL items are dismissed. Some of which may be re-aded to the end of the second list for another ride on the merry-go-round ;-)

Is that what you were asking?
Mike - 2009-09-4 16:03
I suppose, after chewing on it, that I'll not be so afraid of the on-notice tasks this time because the new "rule" is that they can be immediately added back.
Sabrina - 2009-09-4 16:07
Interesting!

It looks like AF4 is the first system in where there is a structured review of 'dismissed' (highlighted) items - where they are rephrased and re-entered into the list right away OR deleted.

In previous systems, dismissed items could potentially stay around forever, and no decision was ever forced to be made on them.

That is some serious motivation. I think I like it.
Carol Davis-Wilkie - 2009-09-4 16:08
Thanks Mike,
I think my brain must be fried because it's the end of a busy week. I basically meant I didn't understand any of the "Instructions as we know so far" but was curious about backlogs, which is my particular demon.... (Yes Mark, if you see this, I still haven't done that backlog from years ago!!!) so I think I will probably have to await the final reveal of the new AF4 at the end of today when Mark issues it. I hope he will do it in his own words as that might help me.

Kind regards,
Carol
ubi - 2009-09-4 16:24
AF4 = ABC METHOD

Looks like there are really three sections to the list:

1. Aside = tasks set Aside a.k.a. dismissed a.k.a. marked for review (highlighted)
2. Backlog = older closed list worked in multiple rounds
3. Current = new open list worked in single rounds
Mike - 2009-09-4 16:29
Yeah, but it is kind of funny ... the list of on notice tasks only lasts one round or so, then it vanishes for a while, to reise from its own ashes ;-)
Joseph - 2009-09-4 16:41
@Sabrina:

Re: AF4 and the "forced" review. Good point! I think you are right. In AF3 review and rewording/dismissing was only done "when it felt ready to be done". Sometimes that might be "never"!

--Joseph
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 16:58
I'm back. ^^

I decided to action a task from my list - I climbed a mountain barefooted. Actually, it's more of a hill (800m high). My feet hurt. :-)

Seems I missed the dismissal. But the documentation, both from Mark and the other readers, is very good.
Mike - 2009-09-4 17:03
Andreas,

Ouch! You're a nut ;-)

What is not yet completely clear about dismissal is:

- Do you dismiss if you don't do EVERY on notice task on the first pass after on notice, or

- Do you get to cycle through the on-notice tasks so long as you do at least one on each pass ... IOW, is it more like an AF1 kind of dismissal or something new entirely.
Sabrina - 2009-09-4 17:11
Mike,

<< - Do you dismiss if you don't do EVERY on notice task on the first pass after on notice, or

- Do you get to cycle through the on-notice tasks so long as you do at least one on each pass ... IOW, is it more like an AF1 kind of dismissal or something new entirely. >>

I think there is some confusion here. My interpretation of this was there are no tasks put 'on notice' - when no tasks are done from the 'backlog', they are dismissed/highlighted immediately.

They are revisited when the end of the list is reached, where they are forced to be re-entered or deleted.

IOW, [Tasks marked for review] = dismissed in AF1 terms.
David Drake - 2009-09-4 17:12
Mark, per my question earlier -- are you going to release the intructions of how to do AF4? It would seem that good people here have figured out most of it....but to hear the official word from you would be nice...

-David
Will - 2009-09-4 17:26
Sabrina,

As I read it, the yellow highlighter = AF1 dismissal.

BUT they are all reviewed on the next pass (no option) and actioned (if only by reentering) or sent back to the pit from whence they came. (I don't get on AT ALL well with my subconscious: does it show?)
Will - 2009-09-4 17:30
Sorry, Sabrina: I think you were saying the same as me.

Mike, if this is a demonstration of the rule, everything goes at the next pass. (I thought I detected an unholy glee in Mark's prediction that we would see some dismissing very soon.)

Crush! Kill! Destroy!
Frank - 2009-09-4 17:41
Regarding the "on notice" items, I think it would make sense to have an AF1 dismissal system for them as well.

Since they have previously not "stood out" (otherwise they would not be up for review), they would most likely all be dismissed immediately but there is always the chance that you might want to rescue a few of them and I think applying the AF1 rules would allow you to do so.

Not really clear to me either at the moment. :)
Gorham - 2009-09-4 17:50
I am really enjoying this live blogging and am very impressed with AF4 so far (and I have tried and liked each previous version very much). I don't think I've ever before had the chance to "watch" someone else working down a list.

Is there a slight mistake? Two items, one at the top and one at the bottom of the list, are numbered 56.
Will - 2009-09-4 17:52
Frank,

You apply the AF1 rule to highlight them for review in the first place. The difference is that you don't get the option of NOT reviewing them at the next pass. They can be rescued by re-entering them on the main list, but only if you feel that they really belong there.
Brian - 2009-09-4 18:34
I wonder when you would draw the line if you're starting out the new system from zero (or migrating from a different system).
Richard - 2009-09-4 18:42
I guess that if you migrate your current list is your 'backlog' and you start with a line under your previous entries.

If you start all over I guess you work one day only with your second (current) list and draw the line the next morning before starting your daily work.
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 19:01
Richard:

<< I guess that if you migrate your current list is your 'backlog' and you start with a line under your previous entries. >>

Correct

<< If you start all over I guess you work one day only with your second (current) list and draw the line the next morning before starting your daily work. >>

No, you draw up your first list (which may be quite short) and then draw a line at the end of it.
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 19:02
Gorham:

<< Is there a slight mistake? Two items, one at the top and one at the bottom of the list, are numbered 56. >>

Very likely. It got quite difficult to remember which number to use at one stage.

Without going back and checking I would think the one at the bottom of the list is the later.
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 19:05
David:

<< are you going to release the intructions of how to do AF4? >>

It's all in the commentary which I put after the list. I will probably consolidate them in the next few days.
Will - 2009-09-4 19:41
Richard,

I started at the 1528 status, with a line at the bottom of my (electrical) book and about to review my "to review/dismissed" tasks either in or out below the line. Worked fine.

I'm using Outlook tasks, with categories for "closed list", "review" and "current task". Outlook gives the timestamps for both created and closed.
Will - 2009-09-4 19:50
If I'd been paying attention, I might have waited for Mark's response before jumping in, since the MarkCam is still running for a few more minutes.
SusanBeth - 2009-09-4 19:54
What do you you do with 'tasks' you want to do, but not immediately? For example, I'm told of a book that I'd like to read but it's not like I'm planning to run right out and buy it. I suppose I could stick "buy XXXX book" on the list right away, but then it would age into the 'backlog' list and then be dismissed and re-entered over and over and over.....

Is there some subsidiary list where you keep 'pended' tasks?
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 19:58
SusanBeth:

<< What do you you do with 'tasks' you want to do, but not immediately? >>

Put a reminder in Outlook Tasks or another reminder system.
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 20:04
Mike:

The review/dismissal rule is as follows:

If you do no tasks when you visit the first part of the list, then all tasks in the first part are put on notice for review and the line is drawn at the end of the second part so that the whole list becomes the new first part.

The next time you go to the beginning of the list, all tasks which are on notice for review are deleted. They may be re-entered (preferably re-phrased) or just dropped. So basically what happens is that you go through each task for review and decide what to do with it.
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 20:07
Mike:

<< the new "rule" is that they can be immediately added back. >>

Yes, they *can* be, but only after thinking carefully about why they haven't yet been done.
Mike - 2009-09-4 20:10
Mark,

Ah, thanks for that. Are the tasks deleted when you go to the first part straight away, or do you have the option to work on them before deleting them. Just wondering why the delay of one list cycle before deleting ... IOW, you could have skipped the "on-review" step entirely and just deleted them if there is no time lapse to work on them. Did I misunderstand? (It happens ;-)

Oh, and just a technicality, perhaps. Once you move the line to the end of the list, there is no SECOND part any longer. You are in the first part straight away. At least until you delete tasks and possibly re-add.
Beth - 2009-09-4 20:10
So, if I'm reading this right, the first/backlog list might be dismissed several times a day?
Mike - 2009-09-4 20:11
Yeah, that is making more sense now.
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 20:11
Mel:

<< When I read "wash up," I envision you washing your hands and possibly your face. Now if you had written "clean up" or "wash dishes" I would have seen you doing what you described. >>

One of those many little differences between British English and American English. "Wash up" or "Do the washing up" is the normal British English expression for "do the dishes".
Mike - 2009-09-4 20:12
Beth,

I think that is right, however it would be a DIFFERENT list each time.
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 20:14
Mike:

<< you could have skipped the "on-review" step entirely and just deleted them if there is no time lapse to work on them. >>

You are right and I did think about making it so one deleted them immediately, but then I decided that deleting them on the next pass would give one's mind more time to process the idea of deletion.
Mike - 2009-09-4 20:16
Gad, I can see how wording the instructions is going to be a challenge. Those of us who have watched you know what you mean (almost ;-) I'm betting you'll have to think up names for the first and second and "on notice" parts of the list.
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 20:17
Beth:

<< if I'm reading this right, the first/backlog list might be dismissed several times a day? >>

It *could* be, but in practice it takes several days to work through the list until there is a danger of dismissal. If I hadn't been keen to demonstrate the process to an audience, I doubt if I would have put so many tasks on notice for review so early. The previous time there were only two tasks left.
Mike - 2009-09-4 20:17
Makes good sense to me.
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 20:18
I just decided to call the not-backlog list "backfocus list" and the open list "frontfocus list". So there. :-P

Since Mark doesn't seem to have made up his mind yet, we should make suggestions. Perhaps something will stick.
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 20:20
<>

That's why I initially doubted we'd see dismissal today.
ubi - 2009-09-4 20:20
AF3 -> AF4 Startup Question:

I think I understand this new method (AF4). I've really liked AF3 (RAF), and would like to be lazy and just draw a line at the end, considering everything now in my notebook to be Backlog, and proceed with AF4 (rather than copying a lot of items or starting with a fresh notebook). So unless I enter several new tasks and work on some, I will get to the beginning of the Backlog almost immediately. In any case, I'll soon need to Review all highlighted tasks and delete/rephrase-reenter all of them before proceeding with non-highlighted Backlog tasks, right?
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 20:20
Mike:

<< I'm betting you'll have to think up names for the first and second and "on notice" parts of the list. >>

Yes, that's why I wasn't terribly keen on calling Part 1 a "backlog" - it gives the wrong impression. Maybe I'll just call them the "closed" and "open" parts of the list. But then I'll still have to explain what I mean by those terms!
Mike - 2009-09-4 20:23
Andreas,

ROTF ;-) Now let's not tease Mark. I'm sure what he most wants is a barrage of silly names to cope with ;-)

Seriously, I suppose "Main" and "New" might be good for the "First" and "Second" lists. I guess "On-Notice" might be as good as anything for the transient list of items ... errrr ... on-notice. ;-)
Mike - 2009-09-4 20:26
Well, for your fans, "closed" and "open" have meaning. And to those who don't know you from Adam, I think you'd have to explain the concept in any case ... so maybe nothing is lost. IOW, if you don't explain the concept of a closed list, there will be all kinds of questions about why you have two "lists" anyway.
Natalia - 2009-09-4 20:30
<>

I think that means the highlighter is not essential anymore, is it? Its main purpose was to make a dismissed item scream: "hey, I've been dismissed! You can come back and delete me or rephrase me or whatever when you feel like reviewing your dismissed items."

Now, with the reviewing of dismissed tasks being ingrained in the system, I think highlighting might be superfluous. Unless, of course, one wants to highlight deleted items, and I can see why one would want to do that... But I am not sure I would want to.

By the way, I think "closed" and "open" to describe the two parts of the lists make a lot of sense.
Mike - 2009-09-4 20:31
"Beginning to flag"? ROTFLMAO ;-) You've got some serious stamina man!
Mike - 2009-09-4 20:33
Natalia,

Yeah, and in an electronic implementation, completed tasks and dismissed but not re-added tasks can just be deleted, I would think.
Greg - 2009-09-4 20:57
Would it be possible if someone sum up AF4 on discussion forum, every post brings new ideas and it would be easier to have it in one place, before Mark write his own in few days.
Mike - 2009-09-4 21:00
I posted a summary recently. Does that need revision?
David - 2009-09-4 21:10
I've got a question. At 14:52, you said "none of the tasks in the "backlog" stand out for action so I have marked them all up for review...At the same time I have drawn a line at the end of the list so that the whole current list becomes the "backlog." All new tasks will now go below this line." In the comments section Wooba asks:

<< What is the rule for placing the line? >>

Your answer is "It goes at the end of the whole list when the previous "backlog" is completed."

So my question is "completed backlog" = either finished all tasks or remaining tasks have been put up for review.

So it it is not necesssary to have carried out the review in order for the backlog to be finished?
Mike - 2009-09-4 21:42
Here is a cleaned up and updated version of the "rules" as I understand them.

=====

Summary of AF4 Rules

AF4 consists of two lists (or list parts)

- The first is a closed list called "Backlog" (for the moment ... it might later be called "Closed List")
- The second is an open list
- The two lists are treated as one with regard to where one is in the processing cycle. IOW, start tomorrow where you left off today.

The processing rules are as follows:

- The first ("Closed") list is cycled through repeatedly and items are actioned (if they stand out), or passed over
- - Actioned items are crossed out
- - - If there is more work to be done (or the task is repetitive, it is added to the end of the second list.
- - If something was actioned in this pass and nothing further stands out
- - - Move to the beginning of the second list and begin scanning/processing that list
- - If nothing was actioned in this pass of the first list
- - - All items are put "on review"
- - - The "backlog line" is moved to the end of the second list making all of that the new "backlog"
- - - All new items are added after the new "backlog line"
- - If (on the next pass of the first list, after returning from working on the second "Open" list) nothing stands out
- - - Dismiss all "on notice" items
- - - Add back any that seem to want to be done to the end of the second list (possibly rewording them

- The second ("Closed") list is processed in only one pass each time it is entered
- - It is processed only when nothing stands out from the first list
- - As with the first list, if an item is actioned it is crossed off and re-added to the end (of the second, open, list if there is more work to do or it is a repetitive item

=====

That is my best understanding so far.
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 21:45
<< The second ("Closed") list >>

Beep! ;-)
Mike - 2009-09-4 21:47
Andreas,

THANKS! I proffed that a dozen times ... if Mark is "flagging", I'm getting punchy ;-) ;-)

I changed it for the next posting (the one in which I fix that and make three more errors ;-)
Mike - 2009-09-4 21:49
LOL ;-) and I also just spelled PROOFed wrong ;-) Oy!
Mike - 2009-09-4 21:54
Boy, the discussion forum is getting royally spammed today. And it is all about that movie. Makes me want to avoid seeing it at all costs.
Sabrina - 2009-09-4 22:26
Mike,

That's a great summary. The only part I am not sure about is this:

>>> - - If (on the next pass of the first list, after returning from working on the second "Open" list) nothing stands out
- - - Dismiss all "on notice" items
- - - Add back any that seem to want to be done to the end of the second list (possibly rewording them <<<

I don't think there is a concept of 'on notice' - here is my interpretation of the workflow to arrive at dismissed items:

1) If no items stand out in the closed list, you dismiss them all.
2) Draw the backlog line at the end of your open list, and it now becomes your closed list, and you work that until no items stand out.
3) When no items stand out in your closed list, do your one pass through the open list.
4) Return to the beginning of the list where the dismissed items, and either delete or re-enter them.
5) Keep going on to the closed list.
6) Go back to Step 1.

(insert favourite terminology for 'backlog', 'stand out', 'dismissed', etc)
learning as I go - 2009-09-4 22:28
Hi Mike and all the listathon audience!
WOWSERS! I'm not even going to attempt to read all these comments......
Mike.....thank you for cracking the code! LOL! After looking at Mark's monolithic list, I think I'll stay with my easier brain damage friendly methods...........

Mark....if you added only 2 more hours, this would be an "official" 17hour crunch! We'd do these during convention and publishing deadlines. David, I hope you appreciate your medical illustration staff each time you get published!
Our methods were far kinder than Mark's non-stop listathon method. We gave ourselves
4 15minute breaks and 2 30minute meals. We'd have NEVER been able to go non-stop like Mark did today! Mark, I'm highly impressed! WELL DONE! If we attempted 15 hours of illustrating in one go, I'd fear that our anatomical accuracy would have flown out the window and the charts, diagrams and schematics rendered utterly useless!
learning as I go
Mike - 2009-09-4 22:35
>>> I don't think there is a concept of 'on notice' <<<

From an earlier post by Mark:

=====
The review/dismissal rule is as follows:

If you do no tasks when you visit the first part of the list, then all tasks in the first part are put on notice for review and the line is drawn at the end of the second part so that the whole list becomes the new first part.

The next time you go to the beginning of the list, all tasks which are on notice for review are deleted. They may be re-entered (preferably re-phrased) or just dropped. So basically what happens is that you go through each task for review and decide what to do with it.
=====
Mike - 2009-09-4 22:43
Learning,

Welcome back ... now it is just about time to walk the dog and see the sunset! ;-)

I'm starting to "get" Mark ;-) If you'll notice his list is mostly small chunks of things. That is why it is humongous. My list would be chunked higher so be shorter ... as I suspect would yours. Mark really is "little and often" in his orientation ... to an extent I had not previously understood. I think that accounts for a lot of our "crossed communications". We are such very different people. I could never watch 30 minutes of a movie. That would destroy it for me ;-)

I'm not sure, but I think with the addition of my "hot list" I could make this system work and it might just work out better for me than what I'm doing now. Dunno. I've got to mull over this a bit ;-)
learning as I go - 2009-09-4 22:57
Hi Mike!
Today was so lovely that I took my beloved furrball on several walks today! Sunsets get prettier in the autumn around here. I'm looking forward to that. Maybe the ocean air has something to do with it. For awhile, the ocean is actually warmer than some of the autumn days.
I barely glanced at the particulars of his list because my brain is like a sieve. I read a list and it evaporates in my brain almost instantly. Maybe it's because it's hard to cue up a list of random short phrases for my brain. Like you, I find it easier to stay in a category of effort as opposed to jumping around. Plus, it's far easier for me to work a short list & routine checklists I've grown more familiar with. I'm a mess. I like deciding and doing separate as much as possible unless it's learning/discovery time. Working an AF list would probably blow a couple of my brain gaskets! LOL!
What titilates you about today's new method to be worth experimenting yet again! I finally stopped with that I hope. I simply don't have the extra resources any more. *blush*
I'd rather use that learning curve effort on something I have more interest in such as playing mad scientist in the kitchen! LOL!
learning as I go
ludlow - 2009-09-4 22:59
I don't think Mike and Sabrina are disagreeing — just using two different phrases — "put on notice for review" and "dismissal" to mean the same thing.

In the time honoured spirit of people criticising Mark's systems before trying them ("it's just a to-do list", etc!) I'd like to sound a pessimistic note and say: I don't see how this system is going to be a long-term improvement, because it weakens the "threat of dismissal" so much. After a few days my brain will learn that there's no real penalty to dismissing items, and thus I will leave the closed list area too readily, reducing the efficacy of the closed list area, and also adding to the overhead time spent rewriting and rewriting bits of the list.

This isn't really a criticism of Mark's work, though. I think NOVELTY is a huge reason why new systems seem better than old ones — the power of our brains to adapt is scarily great. I hereby predict that when all is said and done, the rules of the Ultimate Autofocus System will be as follows:

1. Every few weeks, switch the version of Autofocus that you're using.
The end.
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-4 23:02
Mike:

I think what Sabrina means is that whether you call it "on notice" or "on review", those tasks are not treated like "on notice" tasks in RAF.

Mark writes: << The next time you go to the beginning of the list, all tasks which are on notice for review are deleted >>

You wrote: <<- - If (on the next pass of the first list, after returning from working on the second "Open" list) nothing stands out
- - - Dismiss all "on notice" items >>

The problem is the "if" in your statement. Once the tasks are marked, they get deleted the next time. Immediately, not after nothing stands out again.

At least that's my understanding right now.

I'm going to bed now btw. ^^
learning as I go - 2009-09-4 23:05
Good night, Andreas
Thanks for the fun this morning!
learning as I go
Joseph - 2009-09-4 23:09
Mike:

Let me join in with my thanks for your excellent summaries.

Here's a question about this "on notice" bit. I know there was some talk earlier about the usefulness or not of a highlighter to denote things on notice. In this blogaversity that Mr. Forster is running today he couldn't highlight items, so they were put in brackets.

Does it make sense for us to highlight or mark items on notice at all? The way it looks at first glance is that every unactioned item above the FIRST line is on notice (you've already drawn a SECOND line, right?) When you come back around to the closed list the next time all of those items are dismissed or reentered at the end of the open list. Is that correct?

Is there any reason, besides Mr. Forster wanting to show us clearly what items were on notice for review, to highlight/mark the items?

--Joseph
Frank - 2009-09-4 23:10
Thanks for your efforts today, Mark - I'm sure it has been very instructive for many people, including me. Am using the new system (AF4?) right now and I think it's great.
Mike - 2009-09-4 23:20
Hey Learning,

>>> Today was so lovely that I took my beloved furrball on several walks today! <<<

YAY for you! Honestly, I can't think of a better way to spend the day.

>>> Sunsets get prettier in the autumn around here. I<<<

It is mostly the crap in the air that makes them so beautiful ;-)

>>> 'm looking forward to that. Maybe the ocean air has something to do with it.

AH, I don't think you've ever mentioned you lived near the ocean. Yes, of course, it is the salt in the air. Especially as the air gets colder, the air picks up more salt and that scatters the light more and makes for orange and red sunsets.

I envy you that. I would like to live nearer the water or in the desert ... I love extremes ;-)

>>> For awhile, the ocean is actually warmer than some of the autumn days. <<<

Yes, and especially late in the day. The water has all day to warm up and cools more slowly. The land changes more quickly. It is pretty funny how that all works. When I would fly my tiny plane over the Chesapeak Bay in the warm of a Fall or early Spring day, I would hit a "bump" as I flew over the water ... the air over the water was stil colder and so it was like hitting a pot hole ;-)

>>> I barely glanced at the particulars of his list because my brain is like a sieve. I read a list and it evaporates in my brain almost instantly. Maybe it's because it's hard to cue up a list of random short phrases for my brain. Like you, I find it easier to stay in a category of effort as opposed to jumping around. Plus, it's far easier for me to work a short list & routine checklists I've grown more familiar with. I'm a mess. <<<

Hey now, cut that out! You're one of the most capable people around. And don't even get me started on drive and positive attitude!

>>> I like deciding and doing separate as much as possible unless it's learning/discovery time. Working an AF list would probably blow a couple of my brain gaskets! LOL! <<<

LOL ;-) I also thrive on habits, as you know. That is why much of my lists would be higher order chunks.

>>> What titilates you about today's new method to be worth experimenting yet again! <<<

Oh, I can't resist playing with systems. What I like about this is that he as actually managed to make it simpler than before. I thought that RAF was going in the wrong direction ... getting more complicated. This is much simpler and, with a tweak or two, would be even simpler still.

>>> I finally stopped with that I hope. I simply don't have the extra resources any more. *blush* I'd rather use that learning curve effort on something I have more interest in such as playing mad scientist in the kitchen! LOL! <<<

I also love cooking. My wife is of two minds about it ... MY cooking, that is. On the one hand she loves that I do all the cooking. On the other, she can't get my "experimenting" with food. She would rather that I fix it the same way all the time. Stuff and nonsense, I say. Cooking is play.

I long ago forgot ... one day ... when I was younger and MUCH stupider ... I was cooking pasta. I had read that it was good to put wine in the sauce. I had no wine, unfortunately, but I DID have Creme de Menthe. Need I say more? OY, my dinner tasted like toothpaste!
ubi - 2009-09-4 23:21
AF4 in Brief

I'd like to offer a simpler description of the process. Of course, it doesn't have the detail Mike and Sabrina gave above. I'll use C ("Current") for open list #2, and B ("Backlog") for closed list #1.

Brief Autofocus 4 Instructions (assumed start at Current List)

1. Unicycle C, then multicycle B. Return to C after unproductive B cycle.

2. On return from C to B, cross out each highlighted task.

3. On unproductive initial B cycle, highlight all B tasks then close entire list. Continue to multicycle newly expanded B, skipping highlighted tasks.

I think that covers the entire strategy, other than the details we already know how to do (e.g. choosing what "stands out"; deciding which highlighted items to re-enter and re-word, etc.).
Mike - 2009-09-4 23:23
Joseph,

I'm guessing not. In fact, as I mentioned to Mark, putting items on notice is actually redundant as well. He wants just that little bit of time lag to have his subconscious process that those tasks are about to be deleted. But I think they could be dispatched straight away. Once you did nothing on a pass, copy the items you want to save and draw a big X through the whole bit and move on.
Mark Forster - 2009-09-4 23:27
Mike:

<< I could never watch 30 minutes of a movie. That would destroy it for me ;-) >>

Don't tell me you get a CD of "Lost" episodes, put it on Play All and watch the lot in one go?
learning as I go - 2009-09-4 23:30
Hi Mike
ROTFL ROTFL ROTFL Thanks for the hearty laugh! It adds a new spin to "al dente"/all dental! ROTFL
learning as I go
learning as I go - 2009-09-4 23:32
all of us are lifting Mark on our shoulders for the victory lap! Well done, Mark!!!! You are THE CHAMP!
learning as I go
Joseph - 2009-09-4 23:33
Mike,

Thanks. I'm glad my question made sense. So you are in agreement that whether or not you have that additional subconscious processing time, it isn't necessary to denote items on notice for review because EVERY unactioned item above the first line will be on notice for review?Therefore the first line acts as the marker for on notice items.

Turning to your discussion with Mr. Forster regarding deleting right off instead of putting item "on notice" and then dealing with them the next time you are in the closed list: I'm fascinated by Mr. Forster's consistent consideration of the power of subconscious processing. I think with all his experience in this area he must be on to something. It seems to be one of the hallmarks of the AF system regardless which version.

It makes sense to me. Once you know that everything above the line is on notice, and that the next time you stop by they will be sorted into a delete pile and a rephrase-reenter pile, perhaps you start parallel processing which items aren't ripe, and why certain items are getting done, and how to rephrase items so they will be done. Next time you are there all of this has been subconsciously mulled over and the delete/reenter choice might be made intuitively and quicker in the long run.

Just a guess.

--Joseph
Mike - 2009-09-4 23:36
Andreas spotted an error in my previous version. (Thanks Andreas). Rule numbered 1.4 has been changed to reflect Andreas' correction.

Here is a cleaned up and updated version of the "rules" as I understand them. I numbered the "rules" so as to make it easier to reference them. I also introduced the idea of the "third list" just because someone brought it up and it might merit some discussion. Since it is probably very very transient, I doubt it figures into things very much.

=====

Summary of AF4

The AF4 list structure -- AF4 consists of two lists (or list parts)

- The first is a closed list called "Backlog" (for the moment ... it might later be called the "Closed List")
- Second is an open list
- The two lists are treated as one with regard to where one is in the overall processing cycle. IOW, start tomorrow where you left off today.


[NOTE: There is possibly a third list, of a transient nature, which results from marking all tasks on the first list as "on notice for dismissal", moving the "line" to the end of the second list, and then adding new tasks after that line ... thus resulting in the temporary creation of the third list. This third list is quickly deleted when, on the next pass, all "on notice items are deleted. See the processing details for more information.]


The rules for processing AF4 are as follows:

1. The first ("Closed") list is cycled through repeatedly and items are actioned (if they stand out), or passed over
1.1. Actioned items are crossed out
1.1.1. If there is more work to be done (or the task is repetitive), it is added to the end of the second list.

1.2. If something was actioned in this pass and nothing further stands out
1.2.1. Move to the beginning of the second list and begin scanning/processing that list

1.3. If nothing was actioned in this pass of the first list
1.3.1. All items are put "on review"
1.3.2. The "backlog line" is moved to the end of the second list making all of that the new "backlog"
1.3.3. All new items are added after the new "backlog line"

1.4. On the next pass of the first list, after returning from working on the second "Open" list
1.4.1. Dismiss all "on notice" items
1.4.2. Add back any that seem to want to be done to the end of the second list (possibly rewording them)

2. The second ("Open") list is processed in only one pass each time it is entered
2.1. It is processed only when nothing stands out from the first list
2.2. As with the first list, if an item is actioned it is crossed off and re-added to the end (of the second, open, list) if there is more work to do or it is a repetitive item

=====

That is my best understanding so far. I'm sure there are more errors, so ... ;-)
Mike - 2009-09-4 23:39
Mark,

>>> Don't tell me you get a CD of "Lost" episodes, put it on Play All and watch the lot in one go? <<<

I would not dream of it ;-) I've never seen "Lost". I switched it off after the first 2.5 minutes of the first show and have never wanted to watch it despite all the hype. ;-)

But in general, I see an "episode" as a complete thing. I watch individual West Wing shows because though they are related by characters and overall plot progression, they stand alone.
Christine in Canada - 2009-09-4 23:40
Here's my take on AF v4 - sorry if it seems to be repetitious, but it helps my clarity.

AF 4 is a simple task management system to keep track of things that need to be done, in the very near future. This system does not incorporate project management, routines or other items more easily handled by a calendar or checklist. The list easily manages reference these items.

The entire list is considered to be a whole. The whole is divided into two parts – open and closed. They are separated by a line. Above the line is the closed list, Below the line is an open list. They have different tactics to operate them effectively.

Above the Line – Closed List
- Cycle through this list over and over until there seems to be nothing further to do right now.
– Move to below the line.

Below the Line – Open List
- Do only one pass of the open part of the list continue through to the bottom, then head immediately back to the Closed section.

- Process the Closed list as above (over and over until there seems to be nothing further to do). At this point, before heading below the line, mark all unfinished tasks with a highlighter, as being on review.

- Then proceed to the very bottom of the list. Draw a line to mark this section of the list closed. All new tasks now go below this line.

- Carry on through the new “Closed” section until there appears to be nothing further to action at this time.

- Do another single pass through the open part of the list, continue through to the bottom, then head back to the “On Review- Highlighted” section.
When you reach this section, either delete the items in this section, or rewrite/rephrase them in the “Open” section of the list. The task is obviously not going to be carried out now, for whatever reason, so it’s time to let it go.

Now start to work thorough the “Closed Section” as at the first part, “over and over until there seem to be nothing further to do right now”.

Do one pass of the “Open” part of the list, then carry on back to the “Closed” Section, proceed as aforementioned.


At the end of the day, mark where you stopped working on the list, as a place to start in the morning, and work through the list again.


Having stumbled badly through v2 and v3(RAF), I can see how this one might work well for me. It's actually most like the original AF, which I did find to be the best of the bunch.
Mike - 2009-09-4 23:46
Joseph,

Yeah, to a lot of your assumptions. I'm trying to hold back with tweaks and such. I mean, Mark has not even released it yet and we are already trying to modify it. Imagine his frustration. LOL ;-)

So in my descriptions of the system, I've tried to remain completely faithful to what Mark has been doing. (At lest for now ... muuuuhahahaha ;-)
Mike - 2009-09-4 23:48
Mark,

RE: Copy into notebook. Eeeek. Just print it and glue it in there ;-)
Joseph - 2009-09-5 0:01
Mike,

Yes, I'm certainly of the NO TWEAKS! camp. I've been using AF3 since it arrived without any tweaks at all!

I think my question was not so much indicating a tweak but wondering if the brackets for on notice are only for the sake of "the viewing audience".

--Joseph
Will - 2009-09-5 0:18
Mike,

I quibble with your use of the word "dismiss" in 1.4.1. In previous versions, we have (conf)used "dismiss" as shorthand for "mark for review", whereas here we mean "mark as if done".

Pedantry? Perhaps.
Sabrina - 2009-09-5 0:32
Andreas H:

<< The problem is the "if" in your statement. Once the tasks are marked, they get deleted the next time. Immediately, not after nothing stands out again.>>

Yes, that is what I mean. Thank you for clarifying.
Sabrina - 2009-09-5 0:38
Christine in Canada:

<< - Process the Closed list as above (over and over until there seems to be nothing further to do). At this point, before heading below the line, mark all unfinished tasks with a highlighter, as being on review. >>

If you do at least one task in the Closed list, then nothing is highlighted. Think of it as one big AF1 page - nothing is dismissed until no tasks stand out.

I do hope Mark can write some concrete instructions soon - everyone seems to have their own interpretation right now!

- Sabrina (also in Canada)
Mike - 2009-09-5 0:42
Will,

Well, I don't think we know enough yet. What does Mark do with the items he dismisses? He seems to mark them with a yellow highlighter, as before. Is there reason to think that he does not review them, from time to time, as before and re-add them at a later date? I have seen nothing to suggest that he is doing anything differently, other than adding some back in immediately.

My orientation was to assume as little as possible and just describe what he said and did. I'm sure he will speak to this when asked.
David C - 2009-09-5 8:43
This method reminds me of http://www.markforster.net/blog/2008/11/17/the-simplest-time-management-method.html , which (just) predates AF.
Andreas Hofmann - 2009-09-5 10:00
The squarespace software included the comma in David's link, this one works: http://www.markforster.net/blog/2008/11/17/the-simplest-time-management-method.html

[Thanks, Andreas. I've corrected David's link. Mark]

The similarities are really interesting. AF4 is like a combination of AF1 and this method.
Mark Forster - 2009-09-5 10:19
DavidC and Andreas:

Yes, you're right. There is a very definite resemblance which is not coincidental.

However that system had several major drawbacks:

1) It didn't handle urgent items at all well.

2) Recurring tasks have different desirable frequencies. You probably want to clear your email more frequently than you have a Spanish lesson. If you've got three books and two movies on your list, do you really want to have to deal with all five of them before you can wash the dishes again?

3) Because you ended up with a chunk of difficult items with no way out, it tended to build up resistance to the list as a whole. So there was a big tendency to avoid working on the list.

So, yes, it was definitely part of my thinking along the way. But I had to work through several other ideas before I was able to solve these drawbacks.
Mark Forster - 2009-09-5 10:28
I'm going to close these comments now. Otherwise this discussion will lose its character as an immediate reaction to the unfolding of AF4. You are as always welcome to carry on the discussion in another thread.